Six Ridiculous Questions: P.J. Blumenthal

P.J. Blumenthal

The guiding principle of Six Ridiculous Questions is that life is filled with ridiculousness. And questions. That only by giving in to these truths may we hope to slip the surly bonds of reality and attain the higher consciousness we all crave. (Eh, not really, but it sounded good there for a minute.) It’s just. Who knows? The ridiculousness and question bits, I guess. Why six? Assonance, baby, assonance.

1. Would you make a good supervillain? Why or why not? Describe a day in the life of your potential supervillainous self. Also, we need a supervillainous sobriquet (or two) for you. Also, also, a description of your “lair” would be nice.

A good super-villain”? Me? A counter-question: Are there good villains – I mean as opposed to bad ones? And if so, how does one differentiate a good from a bad villain? Anyway, one person’s villain may be another’s hero. But back to myself. Frankly, real villains have never been my role models. I was once invited to a casting session where a filmmaker was looking for someone to play a Svengali-like villain à la Charles Manson. When it was my turn, the director asked, his queeny voice all business: “Can you be evil?”  Without thinking, I burst into a broad, friendly smile – like the sun blasting out from behind a cloud – and said, “Sure.” “Next!” End of my potential career as a supervillain. My “lair”? Ha. Usually, I just spend my days trying to figure out what I am doing here in this puzzling world. That can happen everywhere, anytime. It’s also the reason I write. My new book of short stories, “Self Portraits” – which is to say portraits of selves – is yet another attempt at documenting the mystery. Anyway, I’m convinced I stumbled into this world by dint of some wrong committed in another not easily describable realm. But wait, not just me. Everyone! My theory is that we are all inmates in a global penitentiary. I am sure though that very few ponder this dilemma. I call myself “Dark Angel”, a moniker for a hero with no power. Still: Darkness attracts, and Angels bring messages. Invisibility and anonymity are my abode, and when you do meet me – which indeed could happen anytime – I never – or rarely – reveal my true identity. Like I said, my fate is not unique in this world, but very few are aware of this true identity – maybe you are? – and prefer imagining they are someone else in some strange somewhere else. 

2. Are concepts like Love and Hate and Good and Evil real? Or are they constructs based on human biochemistry? Explain yourself!

Hmm. I hope you are sitting down. Everything is real: love, hate, good and evil. Fortunately, however, it all ends well. Think of those wretched souls in Dante’s Inferno. The deeper you descend into that realm, the colder it gets…until everything is frozen. But Dante’s Inferno is only part one of a trilogy he describes as a “Comedy”, a divine “Comedy”, “Comedy” is a word that – at least since Aristotle – always promises a “happy end”. But what about its antipode, “Tragedy”?, you might ask. Yes, tragedies do end badly. Think of poor Oedipus. But in Greece, those plays called tragedies were always the first play in a trilogy. The final play, most of which have not survived alas, resolved that tragedy, i.e., happy end.  Dante’s trilogy does the same: a journey from Hell to Paradise. Happy end. As for biochemistry, well, I’m no doctor, I do know however that there are sometimes appropriate medical treatments for all kinds of ailments.

3. Which god is the best? Why?

The question as it stands predicates the possibility of multiple divinities. Is that what you mean? Or are you referring to what some may call “divine forces”? Anyway, I’ve heard that there’s a bar – I forget its location – and that that’s where you’ll run into a guy called “Mr. God” sipping his beer. Yep, same one so many people pray to. Don’t ask me what he looks like, I’ve never been to that establishment. I do know that strangers are constantly hitting him up for a drink though most of the time they actually want something else from him. Some smart alecks even offer to buy him a drink, I hear…kind of as a bribe for a better treatment. But it doesn’t sound like I’m answering your question. Or maybe I just don’t understand it. There are lots of things I don’t understand, and probably “God” is one of them. 


4. Tell me about your favorite book, film, painting, and/or album that doesn’t exist. You don’t have to be the (future, potential) creator though you could be. 

My favorite unwritten book doesn’t have words – at least not the kind you and I are familiar with. My favorite unpainted painting depicts things I can’t find words for – at least not the kind you and I are familiar with. Music is different. It’s mathematical, precise and endless. And we still don’t know all the notes or even the scope of all the scales that might be possible to specify…at least we don’t know them in my neighborhood. 

5. Is AI good or bad? Why?

Hmm. Let me google that. But first I would like to remind you that “artificial” means “not authentic”. Maybe you should be asking whether “not authentic intelligence” is good or bad. Not that I have anything against tools. My local hardware store closed down recently – unfortunately… (too much internet competition – yep, a changing world). Still, I really porked out on tools at the final sale. Tell me: are the tools I bought good or bad?

What happens to us when we die?

PJB: I’d have to ask Viktor. He died about nine months ago and used to make a living selling silver jewelry and Asian statues, bowls etc. at flea markets and antique fairs. He had some pretty good merchandise. I used to buy things from him, I mean sometimes. He was a tough little guy, feisty, ready for a fight even after he turned eighty. At least that’s what he liked to say. I didn’t really believe him. His truck is still parked around the corner from where I live, just where it’s always been. When I walk by it, I always get a…how shall I put it?…feeling about him. Wherever he is, he doesn’t give a damn about that truck anymore or any of his silver and Asian wares. I’m sure of that. He’s somewhere though. I know that too. He just won’t tell where. I guess you’d have to ask Viktor himself to find out the details.

P.J. Blumenthal is an American writer living in Munich, Germany. He is the author of the novel Winston Hewlett’s Impotence (Sagging Meniscus, 2024), a nonfiction book on feral man, Kaspar Hausers Geschwister (Kaspar Hauser’s Siblings), as well as a German-language blog, “Der Sprachbloggeur.” Three volumes of his poetry have appeared in the USA so far: A Lusty Romance, Poems for Readers and Slow Train to Cincinnati.

Kurt Baumeister is the author of the novels Pax Americana and Twilight of the Gods, which was a finalist for the 2025 Big Other Book Award for Fiction. Baumeister is currently at work on three books: American Make-Believe (poetry), Faerie Tales for the End of the World (stories), and The Acrobat (a novel). His writing has appeared in Salon, Guernica, Electric Literature, The Rumpus, The Brooklyn Rail, and other outlets. A contributing editor at Vol. 1 Brooklyn and an acquisitions editor with 7.13 Books, Baumeister holds an MFA in creative writing from Emerson College. He is a member of the National Book Critics Circle and the Authors Guild.

Follow Vol. 1 Brooklyn on Bluesky, Twitter, and Facebook.